Toxicroak

The 2013 Legendary Treasures Toxicroak is a rare Psychic-type Pokémon card with 90 HP, evolving from Croagunk, illustrated by Naoki Saito. Raw near-mint copies trade around $0.38, while a PSA 10 is modelled near $45.38 and a PSA 9 near $18.38. In its original set it is a tough pull — roughly a 1-in-85 booster pull (modelled, not official). Toxicroak has 12 other printings in the catalogue.